Searching ...
New York Real Estate and Property Listings for Sale

Real Estate For Sale In
Middletown, NY

Welcome to ez Home Search, your trusted source for finding the perfect property in Middletown, NY. Explore 124 houses, condos, townhomes, and more, each featuring detailed descriptions and high-quality images. Find one you like and we can help answer any questions and schedule a tour. Our innovative tools, including personalized property value estimates and finance calculators, empower you to make informed decisions. Create your free account today to unlock exclusive features and receive instant updates on new listings. Explore all real estate and properties for sale in NY.
124 Available Listings

Browse our selection of 124 properties for sale in Middletown, NY. Our curated catalog features the latest listings, and our website provides you with all the resources you need to make an informed purchase decision. You will find high-quality property photos, detailed listing descriptions, 3D tours, maps, and relevant community information.

As you delve into the detailed listings, you can save your favorite properties for sale in Middletown, NY, review their latest estimated valuation, and use our mortgage calculator to project monthly mortgage payments, taxes, fees, and insurance. Have a question about a property or the area? Simply ask a question, and our vetted local partner will get back to you.

For personalized financing options and info, complete our contact form to speak with a lender about your financing options, get pre-qualified for a mortgage, or get more information about what is possible.

But why stop at virtual browsing? Schedule an in-person or video-chat tour with a local agent to see your potential new property in Middletown, NY firsthand. Contact a professional real estate agent for further details, inquire about a property's availability, or express your interest in making an offer.

Properties For Sale in Middletown, NY: Market Trends

In Middletown, NY, the real estate market currently features 64 properties for sale. Additionally, 0 properties are under contract and poised to close soon. The recent sales data shows that property sales in Middletown, NY have an average sale price of $225,178 and an average cost per square foot of $143. On average, properties in Middletown, NY typically spend about 147 days on the market before being sold.

The real estate market in Middletown, NY presents a wide array of pricing options, ranging from the most budget-friendly property for sale in Middletown, NY priced at $34,715 to the highest-valued residence listed for $2,770,750. This variety caters to buyers with different financial situations and preferences, ensuring everyone can find a property that meets their needs.

Middletown, NY Market Snapshot
Active Listings 124
Pending Sales 0
Average Sale Price $225,178
Average Price Per Sq. Ft. $143
Days on the Market 147
Last year's property sales 171
Months of supply 0.18

Real Estate For Sale in Middletown, NY: Summary/Overview

Find your dream property in the heart of Middletown, NY. ez Home Search updates listings every minute to give you a wide array of properties across Orange County, spanning 17 distinct zip codes.

Prospective buyers in the Middletown, NY real estate market have various options to suit their various preferences, from construction date and square footage to lot size, design, and the number of stories. Properties in Middletown, NY vary widely in construction date, ranging from as early as 1870 to as recent as 2025, with the majority constructed in 1900. Property sizes also vary considerably, from compact units starting at 735 Sq Ft to spacious estates reaching up to 23,207 Sq Ft.

Lot sizes in Middletown, NY cater to a broad spectrum of preferences, from manageable plots of 0.009999999776482582 acres that are perfect for those seeking a low-maintenance lifestyle to large estates spanning up to 1.399999976158142 acres, ideal for extensive outdoor activities and ambitious landscaping projects.

The architectural styles and structural designs in Middletown, NY are equally varied, with Other being the predominant style across 18 listings. In terms of structure, most properties are 2.0 story properties featured in 124 properties for sale.

For those considering the financial aspects of homeownership, the range of Homeowners' Association (HOA) fees in Middletown, NY varies from $209.9 to $584.0, with 0 properties exempt from these fees. This comprehensive range ensures that prospective buyers like yourself can find a property for sale that fits their lifestyle and budget in Middletown, NY.

Properties in Nearby Zip Codes

Frequently Asked Questions

How many properties are for sale in Middletown, NY?

There are 124 properties for sale in Middletown, NY. More active properties usually means better selection and a little more time to compare before you offer.

What is the median list price of properties in Middletown, NY?

The median list price is $337,000. Median is a clearer "typical" price than average because extreme outliers—like a few luxury estates at the top or a few short sales/fixers at steep discounts—don't pull it up or down as much.

What is the average list price of properties in Middletown, NY?

The average list price is $358,903. Compare average vs. median to read the market's "tilt": when average is higher than median, upper-end properties are likely lifting the market; when average is lower than median, more lower-priced or discounted properties may be in the mix. A big gap in either direction usually means the current inventory is skewed.

What is the median price per square foot for properties in Middletown, NY?

Properties list at a median $237 per sq ft in Middletown, NY. Price-per-foot helps you compare value across neighborhoods and renovations; newer or recently updated properties often sit above the median.

How long do properties typically stay on the market in Middletown, NY?

The median days on market (DOM) is 113 days. Shorter DOM signals stronger demand—expect quicker tours and faster decisions when DOM is low; longer DOM often means you can compare more and negotiate.

What is the housing months of supply for properties in Middletown, NY?

Months of supply (MOS) is 3.8. MOS estimates how long it would take to sell all current listings at the recent sales pace if no new properties were listed. As a rule of thumb, 3–6 MOS is balanced; below 3 tends to favor sellers (move fast, expect competition), while above 6 can give buyers more leverage and time.

How many properties sold in the last 12 months in Middletown, NY?

171 properties sold over the last 12 months. Viewed together with MOS, this gives you a clear read on demand versus supply and helps your ez Home Search partner agent guide you to the best options and strategy.

How many new property listings came on the market in the last 7 and 30 days in Middletown, NY?

3 new listings in the past 7 days and 19 in the past 30 days. Frequent new listings mean fresh choices appear often; slower weeks suggest acting quickly when the right property appears.

How many property listings had a price reduction in the last 30 days in Middletown, NY?

21 listings reduced price in the last 30 days. Price cuts can signal sellers aligning to demand—use them to spot improving values or timing for offers.

Is it more or less expensive to live in Middletown, NY compared with the U.S. average?

Living in Middletown, NY indexes at 269 versus a U.S. baseline of 100 = 100. Above 100 means higher-than-average costs; below 100 means lower—handy context for your monthly budget.

What is the median property size for properties for sale in Middletown, NY?

The median interior size is 1,366 sq ft. This tells you the "typical" amount of living space you'll see at common price points, which helps you set expectations for rooms and layout before touring.

What is the median lot size for properties for sale in Middletown, NY?

The median lot size is 0.11 acres. Closer-in neighborhoods usually have smaller lots; farther out you'll often find more land—compare lot size alongside price-per-foot to balance yard space and interior space.

How many one-story vs. two-story properties are for sale in Middletown, NY?

About 48% one-story, 48% two-story, and 5% three-plus-story properties are active. Single-story properties are often in tighter supply and attract buyers who want fewer stairs, which can lead to quicker sales and firmer pricing when demand is strong.

What is the median year built for properties for sale in Middletown, NY?

The median year built among active properties is 1961. Newer properties typically offer modern systems and energy efficiency; older properties may offer larger lots and classic details, though some may need updates—factor both into your budget and timeline.

Which neighborhoods currently have the most properties for sale in Middletown, NY?

You'll find the most active properties for sale in the Buttonwood, Deer Run, Highland Park Village Condominium Community, Highrose Ridge, Presidential Heights communities. Starting your search there usually gives you more options in a single tour.

What is the typical monthly HOA for properties for sale in Middletown, NY?

The median HOA is $420 per month (where applicable). HOA dues affect your monthly affordability and loan qualification—use our mortgage calculator to see the full picture.

What share of properties for sale in Middletown, NY are houses, condos, and townhomes?

Right now in Middletown, NY, for-sale inventory breaks down to about 71% houses, 17% condos, and 12% townhomes.

How much do you need to make to afford a property in Middletown, NY?

The median property price in Middletown, NY is $337,000. With a 20% down payment ($67,400) and a 30-year fixed at 7.0%, the estimated principal-and-interest (P&I) payment is $1,793/month (plus property taxes, homeowners insurance, HOA dues, PMI if required, and utilities). Based on the 28/36 guideline for housing costs—where total housing expenses should be about 28% to 36% of your gross income—you'd want a household income of roughly $76,870 to $59,788 per year. Use our pre-approval form to know exactly what you qualify for and to be able to make a stronger offer.

How are the schools near properties for sale in Middletown, NY?

Many properties in Middletown, NY are served by well-rated public and private schools; check each listing's school panel for boundary notes and current ratings, then compare nearby options as you narrow neighborhoods.

HOA Monthly Fees of Properties for Sale
$0 0
Less than $100 0
$101 - $500 17
$501 - $1,000 6
Over $1,000 0
Properties For Sale in Middletown, NY: Basic Features

Discover the essential features of properties for sale in Middletown, NY with our detailed listings. Whatever your preferences in size or style, each property offers a range of foundational amenities to enhance your living experience.

Properties For Sale in Middletown, NY: Interior Features
Bedroom Count of Properties for Sale in Middletown, NY
Bathroom Count of Properties for Sale in Middletown, NY
Properties with Fireplaces in Middletown, NY
Homes with 1 fireplace 13
Homes with 2 fireplaces 1
Homes with 3+ fireplaces 0
Homes with no fireplaces 0
Popular Security Features in Middletown, NY
Properties For Sale in Middletown, NY: Exterior Features
Popular Roof Types in Middletown, NY
Metal 0
Wood 0
Concrete 0
Tiles 0
Slate Roofing 0
Asphalt Shingle 0
Composite Material 0
Membrane Roofing 0
Shingles 1
Popular Community Features in Middletown, NY
Waterfront Properties in Middletown, NY
Patio and Porch Features of Properties for Sale in Middletown, NY
Garage Spaces of Properties for Sale in Middletown, NY
Properties For Sale in Middletown, NY: Listing Overview
Middletown, NY Properties Listing Overview
Active Properties Listings in Middletown, NY 124
Properties Listings Under Contract in Middletown, NY 0
Price-Reduced Properties Listings in Middletown, NY 12
Recently Sold Properties in Middletown, NY 171

Real Estate For Sale in Middletown, NY: Demographic Data

Family Composition in Middletown, NY
Families with children 24.26%
Families without children 23.74%
Gender in Middletown, NY
Male 51.97%
Female 48.03%
Population by Age in Middletown, NY
Under 18 26.18%
18-64 59.93000000000001%
65 and over 13.89%
Marital Status by Gender in Middletown, NY
Never Married Male 40.89% / Female 35.79%
Now Married Male 51.06% / Female 47.35%
Divorced Male 6.29% / Female 11.33%
Widowed Male 1.76% / Female 5.52%
Occupied VS. Vacant Units in Middletown, NY
Occupied 11204
Vacant 864
Ownership of Occupied Units in Middletown, NY
Owner Occupied 6149
Renter Occupied 5055
Population by Education Level in Middletown, NY
No Degree 57.52%
Some High School 15.54%
High School 32.1%
Some College 19.03%
Associates 11.99%
Bachelors 12.17%
Post-grad 17.23%
Population of Veterans in Middletown, NY
Veterans 6.37%
Create an account today to unlock benefits like:
  • Saving your favorite homes for sale in Middletown, NY.
  • Email Middletown, NY home listings to your friends and family.
  • Set up a saved search to receive email alerts for new listings in Middletown, NY.

For Sale

Middletown