$2,350,000
- 4
- beds
- 2 full · 1 half
- baths
- 2,800
- sqft
- 1975
- year built
- 4
- beds
- 2 full · 1 half
- baths
- 2,800
- sqft
- 1975
- year built
- Status:
- Active
- MLS #:
- 960930
- County:
- Suffolk
- Listed By:
- Jolie Powell CBR E-PRO - Jolie Powell Realty Inc
- Office Phone:
- (631) 473-0420
- Agent Email:
- jolie@jprealtor.com
Sponsoring Broker: Steven Domber, Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Hudson Valley Properties
Wake up to the water every day. A rare waterfront sancturary that's nearly impossible to find at this price - 4 acres of unparalleled serenity on Flax Pond with mature trees, fig trees, room for a pool! Launch your kayak, watch magnificent sunsets! Pure tranquility, beyond the ordinary. Waterfront living surrounded by nature's finest beauty. Flax Pond Prestige! A waterfront home that shines in every season - 111' of waterfront frontage - One irreplaceable Setting! Set back from the road and positioned on the most sought-after waterfront views of Flax Pond, Crane Neck and the LI Sound with beach access! The home, once a cabin hunting lodge in the 20's was purchased by Mr. Walcott, a Professor of Biology from SUNY Stony Brook in the 60's. A New England native, Mr. Walcott purposely instructed the architect to design a house to appear as an older Saltbox-style home which expanded gradually over many years; hence the multiple roof levels and somewhat irregular layout. While some internal modernization has been undertaken by the present owners, the original character of this house has been respected. Updates include; French drain in basement, filters added to the well, central air conditioning system, inground sprinkler system, Generator, SS kitchen appliances, newer oil burner. The southern meadow, meanwhile, became partially forested and transformed into a scenic lawn, both home to local wildlife, while the northern lawn has reliably served as a front lawn, bird sanctuary, and a thorough and reliable protection against the sea. Bird watch, commune with nature and enjoy the harmony of water and wilderness, experiencing the best of both worlds. A home so warm and welcoming. The house is the bonus....the waterfront is the prize!
Highlights
- Residential
- Single Family Residence
- Built in 1975
- 3.94 Acre Lot
- $1,132/yr HOA
- 2 Car Garage
- 240 days on Market
-
- Bedrooms
- 4
-
- Bathrooms
- 2 full · 1 half
-
- Year Built
- 1975
-
- Architectural Style
- Other
-
- Construction Materials
- Wood Siding, Frame, Shingle Siding
-
- Garage Spaces
- 2.0
-
- Parking Features
- Driveway, Private, Attached, Garage
-
- Living Area
- 2800.0
-
- Interior Features
- High Speed Internet, Eat-in Kitchen, Breakfast Bar, Recessed Lighting, Entrance Foyer, Built-in Features, Natural Woodwork
-
- Appliances
- Dryer, Dishwasher, Microwave, Washer, Gas Range, Other, Stainless Steel Appliance(s)
-
- Flooring
- Hardwood, Ceramic Tile
-
- Exterior Features
- Garden
-
- Patio And Porch
- Patio, Deck
-
- Cooling
- Central Air
-
- Heating
- Baseboard, Oil
-
- Basement
- Full, Unfinished
-
- Acres
- 3.94
-
- Lot Features
- Level, Waterfront, Views, Private, Sprinklers In Front, Sprinklers In Rear, Back Yard, Front Yard
-
- Water Front Features
- Pond, Waterfront, Beach Access, Waterfront Access
-
- View
- Water, Panoramic
-
- Utilities
- Cable Connected, Electricity Connected
-
- Water
- Private, Well
-
- County
- Suffolk
-
- City
- Setauket
-
- Zip Code
- 11733
-
- High School
- Ward Melville Senior High School
-
- Middle School
- Paul J Gelinas Junior High School
-
- Elementary School
- Setauket Elementary School
-
Nearby Schools
-
51out of 100
Public School for 5 Shore Dr, Setauket, NY 11733
Grades: Elementary
Distance: 1.9 mi
-
75out of 100
Paul J Gelinas Junior High School
Public School for 5 Shore Dr, Setauket, NY 11733
Grades: Middle
Distance: 1.74 mi
-
72out of 100
-
52out of 100
-
68out of 100
-
52out of 100
-
54out of 100
-
53out of 100
-
75out of 100
-
100out of 100
Disclaimer: ez Home Search School Ratings are on a scale of 1-100 and represent our evaluation of school quality based on academic performance, school resources, community feedback, and demographic factors. School attendance boundaries are for reference only. Contact the school directly to verify enrollment eligibility.
-
Ask a Question
ez Mortgage Calculator
Enter your details below to estimate your monthly mortgage payment with taxes, fees and insurance.
Please enter a valid number
Cost of the current home: $2350000
Please enter a valid number
Cash you pay when you close
Affects interest rates. 30- or 15- year loans are standard.
Default rate is illustrative, set internally by ez Home Search and updated periodically; actual rates vary by lender, credit score, and market conditions.
Please enter a valid number
Please enter a valid number
Typically 0.25% of home value per year.
Please enter a valid number
Homeowners association dues.
$ 0
Monthly
Principal and interest:
Property Taxes:
Homeowners Insurance:
HOA Dues:
$0 (0%)
$0 (0%)
$0 (0%)
$0 (0%)
The ez Mortgage Calculator is for educational purposes only. Real-world interest rates and payments can differ due to factors like market trends, location, and loan specifics. Calculations are based on your inputs and might not consider extra costs a lender may add, such as insurance, taxes, and fees; thus, actual repayments could surpass estimates. Please note, ez Home Search does not provide loans, and this tool does not promise lending.
Price History
| 10/30/2026 | Price Changed | $2,350,000 |
| Source: OneKey MLS #960930 | ||
| 03/23/2026 | Listed | $2,375,000 |
| Source: OneKey MLS #960930 | ||
Source: MLS Data
Deed History
| 10/08/2025 | Warranty Deed | $0 |
Source: Public records via Constellation Data Labs
What's your home worth?
Calculate your current home value within seconds.
Similar Listings
Look Throughout Setauket
There are currently 29 properties available in Setauket, with 0 under contract to close soon. Properties in the city have an average sale price of $0 and typically spend 136 days on the market before being sold.
Want to compare this property to others available for sale in the area? Use our search to find exactly what you want among our 2,000,000+ listings and to see incredible photos to show you what is possible.
With 108 zip codes in Suffolk County, you have many options in the area. Be sure to claim your free ez Home Search account to make sure you get alerts when a property that meets your needs becomes available.
Source: ez Home Search, MLS Data
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I schedule a tour of 5 Shore Dr?
We can make that happen quickly. Click Tour This Home and we'll connect you directly with our vetted local partner to schedule your visit to 5 Shore Dr.
They know residentials in the area well and can give you the guidance you need to buy with confidence.
How do I get more information about 5 Shore Dr?
Click Ask a Question to talk with our team. You already know it is a 4 bed, 2 bath, listed for $2,350,000. We can talk through recent upgrades, potential seller motivation, how this single family residence compares to others in Setauket, and can even get you in to see the property quickly.
How do I get a virtual tour of 5 Shore Dr?
Yes! A virtual tour is available for 5 Shore Dr. Click here to view the full walkthrough and explore every room at your own pace. If you would like a guided virtual showing or have questions along the way, we can connect you with our local expert to walk you through it live.
How much is the monthly mortgage payment for 5 Shore Dr?
With a 20% down payment and a 30-year fixed loan at an illustrative 7.25% rate, the ez Mortgage Calculator estimates the monthly payment for 5 Shore Dr at around $16,780. This includes estimated property taxes and insurance.
Want to see how this changes with different down payments or interest rates? Jump to the calculator to run the numbers and fine-tune your plan.
How do I get pre-approved to buy 5 Shore Dr?
Stand out in a competitive market by getting pre-approved today. Our quick and private pre-approval process helps you understand your true buying power—no credit pull required to explore all of your options.
Or, let us connect you with our preferred local lender in Suffolk County. They will give you all of your available financing options, based on your specific situation and what is available to you.
Can I negotiate the asking price for 5 Shore Dr?
In most cases, yes. Whether 5 Shore Dr is priced competitively or not, your best offer depends on your personal situation, the seller's timeline, and recent activity in Setauket's market. Our preferred local partner will help you craft a strategy—factoring in comparable properties that have sold, timing, and deal structure—to make a smart, strong offer. Click here to ask about negotiation opportunities.
How do I make an offer on 5 Shore Dr?
We can handle that for you. Our preferred local agent specializes in residentials in Setauket and can guide you through every step of the offer process.
You need an expert who is looking out for your best interests. From market valuation to contingencies and timing, they'll help you present a compelling offer that fits your goals. Click Ask a Question to get started today.
What is the price per square foot for this home?
This home is listed at $2,350,000 with 2,800 sqft of space—that comes out to approximately $839 per square foot.
How long has this property been on the market?
5 Shore Dr was listed on March 23, 2026, which means it's been on the market for 240 days.
Want to keep tabs on it? Click the ♥ to favorite this home and get notified of price drops or changes.
When was this house built?
This home was built in 1975, making it approximately 51 years old.
What is the lot size of this property?
5 Shore Dr sits on a 3.94-acre lot, which is 171,626 square feet.
What schools are assigned to this property?
Based on MLS info, this home is zoned for:
- Elementary: Setauket Elementary School
- Middle: Paul J Gelinas Junior High School
- High: Ward Melville Senior High School
Want to see how these schools compare? Check out our Suffolk County School Guide to see ratings, reviews, and more for the schools in the area.
What are the property taxes for 5 Shore Dr?
The most recent public record shows annual property taxes for 5 Shore Dr were approximately $40,877. This may change with reassessment or exemptions. Our local partner can verify current tax amounts and help you estimate future costs based on your situation.
Is there an HOA fee for this property, and what does it cover?
This home has an HOA fee of $1,132 paid annually.
Is 5 Shore Dr still available for sale?
Yes, this home is still available! Click the ♥ to favorite it so you don't miss any changes—or ask our local expert to schedule a time to see it in person.
Source: ez Home Search, MLS Data
Popular Home Searches in Setauket, NY
Open Houses Near Setauket, NY
Land for Sale Near Setauket, NY
Townhomes for Sale Near Setauket, NY
Waterfront Homes for Sale Near Setauket, NY
Waterfront Condos for Sale Near Setauket, NY
Homes with Pools for Sale Near Setauket, NY
Gated Community Homes for Sale Near Setauket, NY
Homes with No Hoa for Sale Near Setauket, NY
Homes in Adult Communities for Sale Near Setauket, NY
Search Nearby Cities
Search Nearby Postal Codes
Listing information provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed by the MLS. The listing broker’s offer of compensation is made only to participants of the MLS where the listing is filed. Copyright 2026, OneKey MLS. All rights reserved.
Last Updated: November 18, 2026 at 01:31PM | Source: OneKey MLS | MLS#: 960930
