Searching ...

Welcome to 186 Central Avenue. Ideally situated in the heart of the well-established and walkable Village of Lancaster, this spacious two-family property offers an abundance of space, versatility and income potential. Each expansive unit features 4 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, an eat-in kitchen and generously sized living room, providing exceptional flexibility for a variety of living arrangements. The front unit offers a unique two-story layout with three bedrooms on the main level and a fourth bedroom upstairs complete with a walk-in closet. Enjoy added peace of mind with substantial capital improvements including an architectural roof, replacement windows, central air conditioning and updated electrical. Additional amenities include off-street parking and a large backyard. Just steps from village restaurants, shopping, parks and everyday conveniences, this property presents an outstanding opportunity for investors seeking rental income, owner-occupants looking to offset their mortgage with rental revenue, or those in need of a flexible multi-generational living arrangement. With some finishing touches and cosmetic updates, 186 Central Avenue is ready to unlock its full potential.

Highlights

  • Residential
  • Multi Family
  • Built in 1947
  • 0.24 Acre Lot
  • 1 day on Market

  • Bedrooms
    8
  • Bathrooms
    4
  • Year Built
    1947
  • Stories
    2.0
  • Architectural Style
    Duplex
  • Construction Materials
    Vinyl Siding
  • Foundation
    Block
  • Living Area
    3292.0
  • Interior Features
    High Speed Internet, Ceiling Fan(s), Natural Woodwork
  • Appliances
    Gas Water Heater, Water Heater
  • Flooring
    Hardwood, Tile, Vinyl, Carpet, Varies
  • Exterior Features
    Private Yard
  • Cooling
    Ceiling Fan(s), Central Air
  • Heating
    Forced Air, Natural Gas
  • Basement
    Full, Sump Pump

  • Acres
    0.24
  • Lot Features
    Rectangular Lot, Near Public Transit
  • Utilities
    Cable Available, Electricity Connected, Sewer Connected, Water Connected
  • Water
    Public

  • Area
    Lancaster-Village-145203
  • County
    Erie
  • City
    Lancaster
  • Zip Code
    14086
  • High School
    Lancaster High
  • Middle School
    Lancaster Middle
  • Elementary School
    Court Street Elementary

Ask a Question

What's your home worth?

Calculate your current home value within seconds.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I schedule a tour of 186 Central Ave?

We can make that happen quickly. Click Tour This Home and we'll connect you directly with our vetted local partner to schedule your visit to 186 Central Ave.

They know residentials in the area well and can give you the guidance you need to buy with confidence.

How do I get more information about 186 Central Ave?

Click Ask a Question to talk with our team. You already know it is a 8 bed, 4 bath, listed for $249,900. We can talk through recent upgrades, potential seller motivation, how this multi family compares to others in Lancaster, and can even get you in to see the property quickly.

How much is the monthly mortgage payment for 186 Central Ave?

With a 20% down payment and a 30-year fixed loan at an illustrative 7.25% rate, the ez Mortgage Calculator estimates the monthly payment for 186 Central Ave at around $1,990. This includes estimated property taxes and insurance.

Want to see how this changes with different down payments or interest rates? Jump to the calculator to run the numbers and fine-tune your plan.

How do I get pre-approved to buy 186 Central Ave?

Stand out in a competitive market by getting pre-approved today. Our quick and private pre-approval process helps you understand your true buying power—no credit pull required to explore all of your options.

Or, let us connect you with our preferred local lender in Erie County. They will give you all of your available financing options, based on your specific situation and what is available to you.

Can I negotiate the asking price for 186 Central Ave?

In most cases, yes. Whether 186 Central Ave is priced competitively or not, your best offer depends on your personal situation, the seller's timeline, and recent activity in Lancaster's market. Our preferred local partner will help you craft a strategy—factoring in comparable properties that have sold, timing, and deal structure—to make a smart, strong offer. Click here to ask about negotiation opportunities.

How do I make an offer on 186 Central Ave?

We can handle that for you. Our preferred local agent specializes in residentials in Lancaster and can guide you through every step of the offer process.

You need an expert who is looking out for your best interests. From market valuation to contingencies and timing, they'll help you present a compelling offer that fits your goals. Click Ask a Question to get started today.

What is the price per square foot for this home?

This home is listed at $249,900 with 3,292 sqft of space—that comes out to approximately $76 per square foot.

How long has this property been on the market?

186 Central Ave was listed on November 21, 2026, which means it's been on the market for 1 days.

Want to keep tabs on it? Click the ♥ to favorite this home and get notified of price drops or changes.

When was this house built?

This home was built in 1947, making it approximately 79 years old.

What is the lot size of this property?

186 Central Ave sits on a 0.24-acre lot, which is 10,454 square feet.

What schools are assigned to this property?

Based on MLS info, this home is zoned for:

  • Elementary: Court Street Elementary
  • Middle: Lancaster Middle
  • High: Lancaster High

Want to see how these schools compare? Check out our Erie County School Guide to see ratings, reviews, and more for the schools in the area.

What are the property taxes for 186 Central Ave?

The most recent public record shows annual property taxes for 186 Central Ave were approximately $6,814. This may change with reassessment or exemptions. Our local partner can verify current tax amounts and help you estimate future costs based on your situation.

Is 186 Central Ave still available for sale?

Yes, this home is still available! Click the ♥ to favorite it so you don't miss any changes—or ask our local expert to schedule a time to see it in person.

Source: ez Home Search, MLS Data

Popular Home Searches in Lancaster, NY


Search Nearby Cities


Search Nearby Counties


Search Nearby Postal Codes

Listing information provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed by the MLS. The listing broker’s offer of compensation is made only to participants of the MLS where the listing is filed. Copyright 2026, Western New York Real Estate Information Services (WNYREIS). All rights reserved.

Last Updated: November 22, 2026 at 05:01PM | Source: Western New York Real Estate Information Services (WNYREIS) | MLS#: B1729085